The narrator is insane because he is haunted by the idea to get rid of that Evil Eye., The narrator is sane because he understands that the old man didn’t do anything wrong, and that his eye does not make him a bad person., The narrator is sane. He understands the old man’s terror. He describes in great detail what the old man might have been thinking. Yet, he is determined to kill him., The narrator is insane. He says that the old man’s eye “chilled the very marrow” in his bones. He could not see the old man any more. The only thing he was able to see was the eye. He might not understand that he cannot get rid of the eye without murdering the man., The narrator is insane because he claims that he keeps hearing the heartbeat even after having dismembered the body., The narrator is sane because he knew exactly what he needed to do to hide the body. He did everything meticulously without panicking and making a single mistake., The narrator is insane because even when the old man was dead, he didn’t stop. He didn’t have to dismember the body to get rid of the eye. He is driven by pure madness. A rational criminal wouldn’t have gone to so much trouble as dismembering the body when just hiding a whole corpse would have been enough..

counterclaim

by
Embed

Leaderboard

Spin the wheel is an open-ended template. It does not generate scores for a leaderboard.

Visual style

Options

Switch template

Continue editing: ?